Catherine - Microsoft Xbox 360

The nightmare puzzles are genuinely tough but fair, and I love how the story branches based on my choices. Even as a used copy, the disc came in great shape with no scratches that affect gameplay.

I wasn't sure what to expect from a used copy, but the disc arrived clean and the puzzle-blocks in the nightmare stages are surprisingly addictive. The branching story choices kept me glued to the TV for hours.

The puzzle mechanics are so cleverly woven into the story that I kept losing track of time climbing those blocks, even after a rough day. I grabbed a used copy and it runs perfectly, with the save system letting me jump back into the nightmare without any fuss.